The title track, a fictionalized retelling of Joel's experiences with people he met as a lounge singer in Los Angeles, peaked at No.

Following the recording of the show, the live rendition of "Captain Jack" became a staple on the station, ultimately becoming the most requested song in WMMR's history.

Disc 2: Live at Sigma Sound Studios, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, April 15, 1972 Adapted from the AllMusic credits.

[13] Live at Sigma Sound Studios, April 15, 1972 Production Rolling Stone mused that Piano Man "represents a new seriousness and flexibility" for Joel, comparing it to the stylings of Elton John.

[7] Reviewing the album, Billboard stated that it shows that Joel has a "fine shot at establishing himself as consistent quality AM artist with large scale songs and dynamic performing range.