However, in an effort to be inclusive of the larger region beyond Pickering, the club was ultimately named Durham United FC.

[10] Durham United played their first home match against Internacional de Toronto at Kinsmen Park in Pickering, Ontario on June 8, 2014, defeating the visitors 2–0.

[17] After opting out of the 2021 seasons, following the COVID-19 pandemic, it was announced that the club would return to both the male and female divisions, under a new ownership group, Evolution Sports & Entertainment, led by led by principal investors Ritchie Jeune and Chris Rivett, who co-own USL League Two side South Bend Lions FC (Jeune also owns English sixth tier side Kettering Town F.C.

[19] Nevertheless, in July 2023, the league chose to terminate their licence held by Evolution Sports & Entertainment, for the top two tiers for 2024 for both the male and female divisions.

[21][22] They finished in last place in the division in 2024, initially set to be relegated to the third tier League2 Ontario for 2025, however, they were re-instated in the Championship, following Scrosoppi FC B declining their promotion spot.