Later it was sold to Lyman B. Goff, another local industrialist, who made significant alterations to the interior, replacing a great deal of the older woodwork with more fashionable Queen Anne styling in 1881.

He also modified the exterior, but these changes were largely limited to the porch, which also exhibits fine Queen Anne detailing.

[3] In 1941 she donated the house to the Pawtucket Congregational Church for use by the local chapter of the American Red Cross.

[3] In February 2020, local preservationists expressed concern that many of the details of the interior had gone missing, including stained glass at the top of the stairs, several chandeliers, and gates.

[3] The building was sold again in March 2020 to a local artist and contractor, who stated he appreciates the house as "a valuable part of Pawtucket’s cultural heritage" and intends to restore it as an art studio.