The Point Edward Pacers were founded in 1973 as members of the OLA's Junior C League.

After three seasons, including the last two making the division final, the Pacers were promoted to the Ontario Junior B Lacrosse League.

Despite starting off with a losing season and not making the playoffs, the Pacers went 19–1 in 1977 and lost in the league final.

The next two years, the Pacers won both the OJBLL playoffs and the Founders Cup as Canadian Junior B champions.

The Pacers returned to the OJBLL in 1999, putting up winning seasons in five of their first six years back in the league.