First, the temporary pier collapsed, breaking off two courses of iron plates from the caisson and releasing it from its mooring.

The caisson was retrieved and repaired, and in October of that year was set in place.

Renovations were carried out in 1989–2001 in order to arrest deterioration of the now-unoccupied structure.

In 2006, like other Maryland lights, it was made available to non-profits or government agencies who would be willing to take over maintenance, and in 2007 the offer was extended to individuals.

Public auction of the light was cancelled in February 2008, however, "due to safety requirements of the U.S.