At the time the independent level league folded, Port Huron had an 11–14 record and were in fourth place, playing under manager Joe Walsh.
On September 3, 1895, the Marines folded 27–51 record, playing under managers Boocher, Charles Schaub and Thomas Jenkinson.
[6][7] The 1897 Port Huron team joined the reformed six–team Class D level Michigan State League for a partial season.
[10] The team was also called the "Braves" in 1898, with Port Huron joining the Independent level International League.
Rejoining the Independent level International League, Port Huron began playing home games at Recreation Park.
Ending the season with a final record of 12–29, Port Huron placed sixth in the six-team league.
The Port Huron Independents became charter members of the Class D level Border League, which featured teams from both the United States and Canada.
[18][17][19][20][16] The Port Huron Independents continued play as members of the 1913 Class D level International league.
Beginning play on May 24, 1913, the Port Huron Independents placed third in the Border League final standings.
With a final record of 58–63, playing under managers James Pierce, Steve Harder and Billy Kelly, Port Huron ended the season 15.5 games behind the first place London Tecumseh in the standings.
[16] Resuming play in the newly formed eight–team Class B level Michigan State League, Port Huron finished in second place with a 56–38 record, continuing play under manager Johnny Carlin and finishing 8.0 games behind the first place Bay City Wolves.
[31] In the early era, from 1890 through the 1897 minor league seasons, Port Huron hosted home games at the Athletic Club Grounds.
[33][34] Beginning in 1912, Port Huron played minor league home games at Watkins Field.