[1] He struck a hat-trick in Hearts of Oak's 5–1 demolition of Cameroon side Sable de Batie in the maiden CAF Confederation Cup in 2004, which helped to push the club to the top their group, qualify and set up an all Ghanaian final against their fierce rivals Kumasi Asante Kotoko.
[9] After six months, Tagoe moved to another Middle East country, this time to United Arab Emirates and signed for Al Shabab.
[16] As a result of the falsification of the data, Deutsche Fußball Liga requested further medical examinations in order to assess Tagoe's fitness.
[17] On 21 October, DFL announced the health issue was not significant enough to warrant the cancellation of his contract and that the player could be in a position to have his license reinstated pending the results of the final test in December 2009.
[19] Finally, Tagoe made his debut for the club on 30 January 2010, coming on as an 82nd-minute substitute for Boris Vukčević, in a league match versus Schalke 04.
He continued his fantastic start for Partizan with two goals in the first leg of the Serbian Cup semi-final against cross-town rivals Red Star Belgrade.
In late April 2014, Tagoe was unveiled as a new signing of Malaysia Super League side Kelantan FA, penning a six-month contract.
[27] He played one game in the Liga Leumit, the second tier of Israeli football, coming on as a late second-half substitute in a 0–0 draw against Hapoel Nazareth Illit.
[30][31] The port city outfit wanted to give a surprise to the local fans by including a player who had featured in the World Cup, without assessing the present condition of Tagoe, who had not been playing regularly in the last four years.
[32] When he arrived in Chittagong two days before the meet, the team was surprised about his fitness level and physical condition, but nothing could be done about the situation than to include him in the squad because the registration deadline had already passed.
[33][32] Out of six foreign players the 2015 champion brought in with the target to win the title again, it was only Tagoe who could not prove himself fit enough to play a single minute in the three group phase games.
[36][37] The duo scored three goals each during the 2008 Olympics qualifiers but failed to win their final match against Nigeria which ended in a goalless draw.
[38][39] Subsequently, qualified Nigeria to the 2008 Summer Olympics as group A winners after they won their final match against South Africa.
[39] After making his full international debut for Ghana in a friendly against Togo, Tagoe was named in the final 23-man squad for the 2006 Africa Cup of Nations by Ratomir Dujković.
[1][40] Tagoe was selected by Milovan Rajevac as part of the final 23-man squad for the 2010 FIFA World Cup in South Africa.
[41][42][1] In 2006, FIFA.com, also made reference to him being seen as the ''Prince of Darkness'' to his defenders and markers who he could outrun and punish by scoring goals due to his lanky physique and speed.