This game took place in Puebla city on February 7, 1894 in the old Velódromo Park .The match ended 2-0 in favor for Puebla A.C ,'The Two Republics states that the goals were scored by TR Phillips who went on to found Reforma AC, and Claude Butlin (the first highly trained athlete to migrate to Mexico).

This match fuelled the interest in this new sport which was short lived being that cricket had become more popular and had become more organized with clubs popping in and around Mexico .

In 1904 Puebla would finally join the Primera Fuerza taking this time to better establish once again its football club.

In their first tournament in 1904–05 Puebla lost all games and didn't score a goal in the 8 matches played, therefore finishing last.

Due to the lack of opponents, having only one with neighboring town San Martín Texmelucan, the club would be forced to go Orizaba, Veracruz to find competition where they participated for a few years in the old "Liga Veracruzana de Fútbol".