However, at the end of 1927–28 season with league re-organisation and the number of West Lothian clubs dwindling, they decided to turn amateur and leave the Juniors.

On the way to the Final they defeated West Calder United, Dalkeith Thistle, Tranent, Thornton Hibs, and Parkhead.

The club was re-formed and joined the East Region in 1990–91, once again bringing Junior football back to Recreation Park.

Pumphy won the Scottish Junior Football East Region Premier League South title in 2018–2019.

The following year they won the League and League cup double.They joined the East of Scotland pyramid system at tier 9 where they are playing at the moment in the Third Division Source As of 31 October 2022[3] Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules; some limited exceptions apply.