The Monsignor Edward Pace High School Spartans won the state title his junior year and he was named to the Dade-Broward All-Star game.
In November 2004, Andrews narrowed his list down to his top five schools, which were: Florida, Miami (Fla.), Georgia, West Virginia, and Kansas State.
[8] On January 14,[2] he visited West Virginia and gave them a verbal commitment, however it was not announced until two weeks later.
During a skeleton drill, a drill in which there is no offensive nor defensive linemen and rushing of the quarterback is not allowed, one day in March, Andrews hit starting quarterback Pat White, which instigated a scuffle between Andrews and several offensive players.
[13] In 2007, Andrews missed the Blue-Gold Spring Game due to off-field issues reported by head coach Rich Rodriguez.
In the season finale, the 48–28 win over Oklahoma in the Fiesta Bowl, he recorded seven tackles and an interception of Sam Bradford in the endzone.
He had also decided that he needed to change, because he didn't want people to think that he was a "street thug," and that he would not be as confrontational with coaches as he had been in the past.
Andrews finished his junior season with 77 total tackles, 4 for a loss, a sack, one interception, and a fumble recovery.
Following the West Virginia Mountaineers' Meineke Car Care Bowl victory over North Carolina, Andrews was dismissed from the team by head coach Bill Stewart.
[15] After going undrafted in 2010, Andrews played for the Green Bay Blizzard of the Indoor Football League in 2010.
He advanced to the Arena Football League in 2011, playing for both the Utah Blaze and San Jose SaberCats.