This combination split at the end of the 1929 season and Reynella returned to the Mid-Southern Association.

Reynella joined the Southern Football Association in 1948 where they have remained ever since.

The Reynella FC continues to field teams in Senior and Junior grades in the Southern Football League.

In 2018 Reynella introduced its first female teams in the inaugural SFL female competition and in 2023, Reynella FC won its first A-Grade Women's premiership in the Southern Football League.

Reynella FC has produced a number of Australian Football League (AFL/VFL) players including Michael Doughty (Adelaide), Ben Moore (Richmond), Darren Kappler (Fitzroy, Hawthorn, Sydney), Andrew Brockhurst (Fitzroy), Brenton Harris (North Melbourne), Darren Harris (North Melbourne), Matthew Golding (Adelaide), Justin Bollenhagen (Fremantle), Cory Gregson (Geelong), Sam Draper (Essendon), Jack Delean (Fremantle).