A right-handed batsman and right-arm seam bowler, Hutton's bowling was probably his stronger discipline, but he was considered an all-rounder.

Hutton made his Test debut in a drawn match against Pakistan in 1971, being promoted to open in the second innings and scoring 58 not out in his maiden Test innings.

He shared a century partnership for the seventh wicket with the wicket-keeper Alan Knott, after the Indian spinners did some early damage.

A surprise choice for the World XI tour of Australia in 1971–72, he struggled playing alongside the biggest names in international cricket.

In 1980–81, he toured Bangladesh with the Marylebone Cricket Club (MCC) team.