After attending Clackamas Community College, McCoy attended college at Dakota Wesleyan University, where he played on the school's baseball team.
After graduating from Dakota Wesleyan, McCoy served as an assistant baseball coach at Dakota Wesleyan in 2003, James Madison University in 2006, and Niagara University from 2007 to 2008.
[1] McCoy was named interim head baseball coach at Niagara University for the 2009 season.
[2][3] Following the conclusion of the 2009 season, McCoy was named the head baseball coach at Niagara on a permanent basis.
McCoy achieved his 300th career win as a head coach on February, 14th 2025.