[7][6] Royal Wahingdoh holds the record for the highest number of consecutive Shillong Premier League titles, having won the finals in December 2010, 2011 and in 2012.

[22] In the First Division 2009 season, they created a record by winning all their games besides scoring 52 goals en route to lifting the title and along with it, an entry into the top tier of Meghalaya football, the Shillong Premier League.

[27] In 2014, Royal Wahingdoh achieved their biggest success after winning the I-League 2nd Division,[28] then second tier of indian football league system.

[37] Santosh Kashyap was appointed the head coach for newly promoted Royal Wahingdoh before the start of the 2014–15 I-League.

[38] They signed Trinidad and Tobago international Densill Theobald as marquee player, who represented his nation at the 2006 FIFA World Cup.

[46] Under his coaching, Royal Wahingdoh stun eventual champions Mohun Bagan by 3–2 margin,[47] and ended the season in third position with 30 points in 20 league matches.

[48][49][50] After finishing third in the top tier domestic league, Royal Wahingdoh pulled out of I-League and Santosh Kashyap left the club.

[51][52][53] Though the club was granted a national license to compete in 2015–16 I-League, they decided to pull out, citing lack of a clear roadmap for the league as the reason.

The final was won 3–1 against Rangdajied United who fielded their first side including Babatunde, Jeribe, Enyinnaya and Argha.

[76] Though the club was granted national license to compete in 2015–16 I-League, they decided to pull out, citing lack of clear roadmap for the league as the reason.

The club had earlier failed to comply with AFC licensing criteria as their home stadium did not adhere to the credentials.

[111][112][113][114] They also participated and won the title of Meghalaya U-14 Championship under guidance of head of youth development, Bobby Nongbet,[115] in which Rheadolf Nongneng emerged as top scorer with 16 goals.

[111][116] In the 2016–17 season of Nike Premier Cup, Royal Wahingdoh finished as runners up, losing to Minerva Punjab.

[123][124] On 17 August 2015, they clinched Independence Day Cup title, beating Sanbhalang FC 8–1 in the final at Jawaharlal Nehru Stadium, which was organized by Meghalaya Football Players' Association.

[125] In 2016, the team coached by Iaikyntiew Marbaniang, took part in preliminary round of the Indian Women's League held in Cuttack, Odisha.

[126][127] Thus the club became first and only team from Meghalaya to feature in the IWL; they later received invitation from Shillong Sports Association to play in the inaugural state women's football league in the East Khasi Hills.