The following year, he won a parliamentary by-election for the Elizabeth constituency triggered by Malcolm Adderley's resignation.
At the time of his election, Pinder was the youngest PLP MP and one of only two MPs born after independence.
After being reelected in the 2012 general election,[4] Pinder served as the Minister of Financial Services until his resignation in December 2014.
Following that, he spent a year with Deltec, a private bank, and then in 2015 joined the law firm of Graham, Thompson & Co as a partner.
When the PLP defeated the FNM in September 2021, Pinder was appointed Senator by Prime Minister Philip Davis and to the Office of the Attorney-General and Ministry of Legal Affairs.