The return leg in Saint Lucia ended in a 4–2 victory after 90 minutes, sending the tie into extra time, and then to penalty kicks.

Saint Lucia won the shoot-out 5–4 and advanced to the main draw for the 2014 FIFA World Cup.

Saint Lucia were eliminated from World Cup qualification after finishing last in their group with one point as a result of one draw and five losses.

In 2014 the team won the Windward Islands Tournament after beating Dominica 2–0, Grenada 1–0 and a tie with Saint Vincent & The Grenadines.

Win Draw Loss Fixture Barakat 26' The following players were called up for the 2024-2025 CONCACAF Nations League B matches against Saint Martin on 11 and 14 October 2024.