[1] Reynolds attended Davis Senior High School, where he played for the Ashley Yudin–coached Blue Devils who were undefeated for two seasons and won two CIF Section championships.

Reynolds played his youth soccer for the Davis Devils and in 1999–2000 for the River City Rush, a CYSL team coached by Marcos Mercado that won the California State Cup Championship (U-18) in 2000.

Reynolds also played for the United States Adult Soccer Association California-South Region IV team that won the 2004 George F. Donnelly Cup, the US national amateur championship.

[6] He made three starting appearances in 2008, earning a 1–1 draw on the road against the Vancouver Whitecaps[7] and two shutout victories against the Rochester Rhinos[8] and Atlanta Silverbacks to close out the Miami season with a .33 goals against average.

In February 2012 Reynolds played goalkeeper for the United States Men's National Beach Soccer Team coached by Eddie Soto at the Cancun Cup.