[1] Garrett faced Betsy Ruth, Isis The Amazon and Jessika Haze in a Fatal Four-way match on December 12, where she successfully retained the Ladies Championship.

[1] On October 2, Garrett teamed up with JD Amazing in a winning effort defeating Jason Hanley and Shooter Storm in a mixed tag-team match.

[1] Garrett went on to defeat Black Tigress, Danny Demanto and Christina Von Eerie to earn another shot at the title.

[1] Santana made her debut for Pro Wrestling Xtreme on June 18, 2011, at the PWX Wrestlewar, where she was defeated by former WWE Diva Jillian Hall in her return match.

[7][unreliable source] On January 28, Garrett faced Christina Von Eerie at her next appearance at Pro Wrestling Xtreme, where she failed to win.

[1] On October 14, Garrett teamed up with Rance to defeat Cherry Layne and Mike Reed in a mixed tag-team match.

[1] Garrett made her debut for Southern Championship Wrestling Florida on June 4, where she defeated The DTW Ninja.

[8][unreliable source] Garrett made her debut for Shimmer Women Athletes, on September 27, 2012, at Volume 50, where she competed against Mercedes Martinez in a losing effort.

[14] On March 28, 2015, Garrett defeated La Rosa Negra to win the Ring Warriors Battling Bombshells Championship.

[18][19] On the May 3 edition of Impact!, Garrett along with Jordan debuted their new interview segment, O-Zone, during which Orlando attacked and started a feud with the Global Champion Rob Terry.

[27] Garrett faced Brandi Wine on the August 25 at the Shine 12 event, which ended in a draw after an interference by Malia Hosaka.

[30] On December 13 at Shine 15, Santana and Amber O'Neal lost to the S-N-S Express and due to the pre-match stipulation were forced to disband.

[35] Garrett returned to TNA at the Knockouts Knockdown on March 17, 2013, where she competed as a villainess in a losing effort against Brooke Tessmacher.

[3] On January 27, 2014, it was announced by the promoter of Shine Wrestling, Sal Hamaoui, that Garrett has signed a contract with TNA,[36] which was later confirmed by PWInsider on February 14.

[39] On the April 10 episode of Impact Wrestling, Brittany competed in a fatal four-way match to determine the next number one contender to Rayne's TNA Women's Knockout Championship, which would be won by Angelina Love.

[41] On the May 22 episode of Impact Wrestling, Brittany received her first shot at the TNA Women's Knockout Championship against Angelina Love, but was unsuccessful in capturing the title.

[42] This led to a tag team match, where The Beautiful People defeated Kim and Brittany on the May 29 episode of Impact Wrestling.

[45][46] On the following episode of Impact Wrestling, the evil Brittany once again challenged for the Knockouts Championship in a four-way match, losing to defending champion Gail Kim.

[31] On October 16, 2015, Garrett made her debut for Japanese promotion World Wonder Ring Stardom, during their first American tour in Covina, California.

[56] On May 21, Garrett took part in a tournament to crown the inaugural SWA World Champion, where she was defeated by Toni Storm in the semifinals.

[3][1] However, on the third season of WOW, Caged Heat's attorney Sophia Lopez was able to convince WWA (Women Wrestling Association) that they should vacate The All American Girls' championship, and so they did.

As The All American Girls faced Caged heat in the first round of the vacated WOW Tag Team Championship, O'Neal turned on Garrett, causing them to lose their match.

[58] Garrett made her return on the season finale, defeating her former partner O'Neal and the WOW World Champion Jungle Grrrl to win the championship for the first time.

[59] As WOW premiered on AXS TV which aired on early 2019, Garrett got into a heated feud with Tessa Blanchard.

[62] In 2016, though not signed to WWE, Garrett made three appearances on NXT, losing to Asuka,[63] Emma and Billie Kay.

On July 13, 2017, Garrett returned as part of the Mae Young Classic, being eliminated from the tournament in the first round by Piper Niven.

In mid-August 2019, it was announced that Garrett had been officially signed to a contract and would report to the Performance Center before she appeared in the developmental company NXT.

On the July 1, 2020, episode of NXT, Santana was effortlessly destroyed and defeated by the returning Mercedes Martinez who no-sold her offense.

[67] She came back to Women of Wrestling in December 2023 to team with Americana as the "All American Girls" feuding with Amber O'Neal & Jessie Jones.