[11] Evans began playing the recurring role of police officer Oliver Fish on One Life to Live on January 15, 2008.

[12] He subsequently appeared briefly on Guiding Light as Trey in 2008, and guest-starred as Woody Sage in the June 22, 2008 Law and Order: Criminal Intent episode "Betrayed" as well as the role of Ben in the October 21, 2008, Fringe episode "The Cure.

[2] In July 2009, his character Oliver Fish became involved in a romantic relationship with Kyle Lewis.

Evans also had a guest role on the AMC series Rubicon as an American involved in a serious terrorist attack with al-Qaeda.

In June 2024, Deadline announced that Evans had been cast in Mindy Kaling's forthcoming series Running Point.