He is a founding member of The Casitas Group, an independent theater company started in 2008, alongside Troian Bellisario.
[2] Coffey's first acting part was playing Patrick for one episode on Summerland alongside Jesse McCartney.
[2] In January 2012, Coffey joined the recurring cast of Pretty Little Liars as Holden Strauss, an old friend of Aria's, who becomes her way of covering when she's actually going to see Ezra Fitz.
In 2012, he wrapped on a short film called Exiles, a modern rendition of Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet with a twist.
Coffey plays a lead role in the 2016 film Sugar Mountain, directed by Richard Gray.