Shane O'Neill's, founded in 1905 and named after the 16th-century Ulster king Seán an díomais Ó Néill, is essentially a continuation of the first club.

[11] In 1941, Shane O'Neill's won the Armagh Junior Football Championship, defeating Ballyhegan by 0–10 to 1–02.

In the same year they were runners-up in the All-County League, and participated in the Kilmacud 7s and Ulster and All-Ireland Féile competitions.

In 2010, the U-12 and U-14 teams won their respective county League and Championship titles, and the U-14s were runners-up in the All-Ireland Féile.

Little is known of its early years, but from 1940 the club participated in the Newry and District Camogie League, reaching the final in 1943.

[16] In the club's centenary year, 2005, a new clubhouse and pitch were opened at Páirc Sheáin Uí Néill, on the south side of the Newry Road just outside the village, with a challenge match between Armagh and Louth.

[9] The club is currently raising funds for extensions and improvements to the playing fields and clubhouse, estimated to cost £500,000.