"[1] They were thinking of several lyrics until Myrick added a guitar riff, and they thought of the title, "She's Country."

He described it as having "dumbed-down lyrics and amped-up, rock-based production", and said that it was a "step backwards" from his previous singles such as "Laughed Until We Cried".

[2] Blake Boldt of Country Universe gave the song a C− grade, saying that its lyrics were "cliché-laden" and sexist because of the oversimplified terms used to describe the women.

[3] Aldean debuted the song in November 2008 at the Country Music Association awards shortly before its release as a single.

The song became Aldean's first Top 40 hit on the Hot 100 chart after peaking at number 29.