It was released on the White Whale record label and reached the top 20 of the Billboard Hot 100 chart during the same year.

"She's My Girl" is a psychedelic song[1] written by Alan Gordon and Gary Bonner.

[3] The song begins with theme and lyrics inspired from jazz, moves into a pop music refrain, and later shifts into 34 time.

[1] In spite of this obstacle, the song peaked at #14 on the Billboard Hot 100 and spent ten weeks on the charts.

[6] In reviewing the Turtles' legacy in 2016, Steve Horowitz wrote that among a few other hits from the group, the song "still holds up today" and is regularly played on radio stations featuring music from the 1960s and in films depicting the decade.