The EP contains a 1986 studio re-recording of a song from the band's debut album on Side A and two demo tracks originally recorded in 1982 on Side B. SNFU planned to issue a new 7" record after their second album, If You Swear, You'll Catch No Fish, was delayed.

[1] For Side A, they recorded a reworked version (listed as a "dunce mix") of the EP's title track.

They were recorded in the studios of CJSR-FM and originally had been intended for a compilation of underground Edmonton bands to be titled West Watch.

She's Not on the Menu was limited to 500 copies on colored vinyl, and was packaged with original artwork by singer Ken Chinn.

[1] "She's Not on the Menu (dunce mix)" was reissued on the compilation album The Last of the Big Time Suspenders.