[2] Competing with the Saugeen-Maitland Lightning of the Lower Lakes Female Hockey, she captured a bronze medal during the league's 2013 postseason.

Later that year, Tiley was named to Team Ontario Blue, where the roster would capture a silver medal at the 2013 National Women's Under-18 Championships.

As a freshman, Tiley helped the Golden Knights qualify for the NCAA Tournament, appearing in the quarter-finals, while pacing all ECAC Hockey backstops in goals against average with a minuscule 1.16.

Making her CWHL debut on October 14, 2018, Tiley allowed two goals in a loss to the Shenzhen KRS Rays.

Standing between the pipes for Team Sonnet (Toronto), Tiley participated in the 2021 Secret Cup, which was the Canadian leg of the 2020–21 PWHPA Dream Gap Tour.