The inaugural tournament was won by The Wednesday, who defeated Heeley 4–3 in the 1876–77 final.

The current champions are Worksop Town, who won their record 14th title after defeating Penistone Church 5–0 in the 2023–24 final.

[3] Worksop Town, along with Frickley Athletic and Sheffield Wednesday is joint-record holder for the most titles won.

This section lists every final of the competition played since 1876, the winners, the runners-up, and the result.

The competition was open to the more senior non-league clubs in the region as well as the reserve teams of the area's professional (Barnsley, Doncaster Rovers, Rotherham United, Sheffield United and Sheffield Wednesday).