[3] In June 2018, Rutherford was named in the Cricket West Indies B Team squad for the inaugural edition of the Global T20 Canada tournament.
[5] Rutherford made his Twenty20 debut for Guyana Amazon Warriors in the 2018 Caribbean Premier League on 9 August 2018.
[6] In October 2018, Rutherford was named in the squad for the Khulna Titans team, following the draft for the 2018–19 Bangladesh Premier League.
[8][9] In June 2019, Rutherford was selected to play for the Edmonton Royals franchise team in the 2019 Global T20 Canada tournament.
[12][13] On 11 September 2021, Rutherford was included in the Sunrisers Hyderabad squad for the second phase of the 2021 IPL as a replacement player for Jonny Bairstow.