Allred won the ISWA State Finals triple crown in 2017, making the USA Wrestling Cadet National Championships.

[9] A week later, Allred would wrestle as an extra again against Iowa, winning his first collegiate match after he beat Connor Corbin by major decision.

[16] He made his dual-meet debut on November 4, beating North Dakota State's Owen Pentz 4–2 in sudden victory.

[18][19] On February 7, Allred was named Big Ten Wrestler of the Week after earning pins over Zac Braunagel and Hayden Copass.

[22] Allred then received an automatic berth to the 2023 NCAA Division I Wrestling Championships,[23] where he would reach the quarterfinals before being handed his first loss against Nino Bonaccorsi by way of a 5–3 decision.

[24] Allred's season would end in a 1–0 blood round loss to Jacob Warner, one win away from gaining All-American status.

[28] Nebraska began the 2023–24 season against North Dakota State, where Allred would pick up a 20–4 tech fall victory over Spencer Mooberry.

During the first period, Allred would hit his head on Rasmussen's knee, sending him into concussion protocol, and forcing him to medically forfeit out of the match.

Brooks defeated Allred by major decision, sending him to the consolation semifinal round to face Luke Geog.

[37] He would then lose to Jacob Cardenas in the blood round to finish one win away from gaining All-American status for the second straight year.

[39] In Nebraska's wrestle-offs, Allred pinned true freshman Marco Christiansen in the first period, earning a starting spot.