Once revealed, the three hosts begin interviewing the mystery guest.

[4][5] SiriusXM acquired the podcast from Amazon in 2024 for a reported US$100 million.

[6] On May 23, 2023, Max premiered a six-episode documentary-style special following the podcast's North American six-city tour, which began in February 2022, featuring behind-the-scenes footage and celebrity interviews.

[9] In a positive review for The Irish Times, Fiona McCann stated that "the camaraderie between hosts and guests often works to disarm the latter and allow for something fresher than your usual famous-person-talking show".

[10] In November 2024, Apple announced that the podcast was the 5th most popular show on its platform in 2024.