[2] Similarly on the website Bum's Corner, Porfle wrote that "while there are a few moments of awkward melodrama along the way [...], most of Soccer Mom is light, fluffy comedy that doesn't come close to the dizzying heights of wackyness we used to get from those old Disney comedies like Freaky Friday and Superdad, but is still harmless fun", while praising Pyle's performance and those of Steve Hytner and Dan Cortese, though not being impressed with Osment and giving the film 3 stars out of 5.

[3] The same rating was given by Joly Herman for Common Sense Media, who found the film to be "pretty light fare" and "some of the plot twists [...] a little predictable" but liked Pyle's and Osment's performances as well as the focus on girls' sports and opined that "moms and daughters will enjoy watching it together".

[4] On DVD Verdict, Erich Asperschlager was critical of how Pyle looked in man makeup, but wrote that "once you get past the premise and the makeup, Soccer Mom is a middle-of-the-road kids flick with a good message about family—even if it's the same message found in plenty of better movies", going to praise Pyle, Osment, Cortese as well as Cassie Scerbo and concluding that the film "succeeds more than it fails, and ultimately fares better than a lot of its family movie competition".

[5] Home Theater Info, finally, only awarded the film 4 out of 10 stars, but remained mostly positive, concluding that "this is fun on a juvenile level but just perfect for that rainy Saturday afternoon when the kids are stuck in the house".

[6] The film features the 2009 song "Don't Change for Me" by Matthew Moon in the closing credits, which was later covered by Gin Blossoms on their 2010 album No Chocolate Cake.