[1] All three teams now play in different leagues: Newberry in the South Atlantic (Division II), Presbyterian in the Big South (FCS), and Wofford in the SoCon (FCS).
Erskine College was also a member from 1946 to 1951 when it dropped its football program.
Erskine has announced that their football program is returning for the 2020 season.
The College of Charleston was also a member of the South Carolina Little Five in basketball, now playing in the Colonial Athletic Association, but the post-season basketball tournament was always for the South Carolina Little Four and the College of Charleston was not invited.
† = Qualified to the NAIA Men's Basketball Championships