South Carroll High School State Champions Additionally, South Carroll High School counts two former varsity athletes as notable alumni.

Josh Boone and Marshall Strickland both played men's basketball in the late 1990s and early 2000s (decade).

Boone went on to win an NCAA Division I championship in 2004 as a forward on the University of Connecticut men's team and was drafted in 2006 by the NBA's New Jersey Nets as the 23rd overall pick.

In 2021, The Cavaliers varsity football team went 12-0 and made the 1A/2A MMPSAA State Championship, But lost to Dunbar High School.

The South Carroll wrestling team has crowned more individual state titles than any other public school program in the state, making South Carroll the winningest wrestling program in Maryland Public school history.