In 1877, the congregation purchased the block of land bounded by Marion, Twiggs, Morgan, and Madison Streets, where they are presently located.

Their design for St. Andrew's incorporated several components from the original wooden church, including the stained glass windows, communion rail, and lectern.

[5] As Tampa's population grew and the city expanded, St. Andrew's parish helped to establish the local Episcopal congregations of St. John's and St.

[4] Next door to the historic church, on the same block at the corner of Twiggs and Marion Streets, is the six-story Western Union Building.

The Art Deco styled, commercial office building built in 1929 was purchased by St. Andrew's Episcopal Church in 1996.