[2] St. Mary Catholic Church in Menasha opened an elementary school in the late nineteenth-century, adding high-school grades when opening a new building in 1928.

A three-story building, it contained a gymnasium, cafeteria, and all the other typical amenities associated with a high school of the day.

The school stayed open until the spring of 1997 when a new building was erected in the Town of Menasha, now Fox Crossing.

Since 1997, additional facilities have been added, including the EEEC Energy Center; Jane's Woods, a two-acre wildlife sanctuary; and Zephyr Fields, a new football/soccer stadium.

[3][clarification needed][citation needed] However, in the early 2000s WISAA dissolved and the school entered the Olympian Conference in the Wisconsin Interscholastic Athletic Association (WIAA).