The church is Grade II listed by the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport as it is a building of special architectural or historic interest.

[1] The foundation stone for the restoration in 1896 was laid on 18 October 1896[2] by Lady Byron of Thrumpton Hall.

A small organ dating from 1840 was bought in 1871 from St. Stephen's Church, Sneinton.

It was sold to Lady Bay Church in 1898 when the next pipe organ by Charles Lloyd and Co built at a cost of £500 (equivalent to £71,100 in 2023)[4] was opened on 22 November 1899[5] Although provision was made for three manuals, only two were initially fitted with pipes as an additional £300 was required to complete the work.

It was enlarged in 1919 when it was moved to the newly constructed King George Aisle.