The church's current building is largely the result of 19th-century reconstruction, but it retains its 13th-century tower with a later timber belfry.

The main body of the church with its large high pitched roof dates to the second half of the 19th century.

In 1881 the interior was laid out in its present form and the church was rededicated to Saint Nicholas (having previously been dedicated to St. Mary).

The columns have octagonal stone bases and square decorative capitals; they now support the lowered roof-line.

[2] A number of bullet holes from musket shots from the skirmishes in the Civil War can still be seen even following the restorations, notably on the soffit of the upper storey round-headed window on the north wall of the tower.

It was listed because it "is of special historical interest for its successive reconstructions and retains elements of each, from the well preserved medieval tower, to the work of the early C19, to the remodelling of 1867.

[5] As a result of the decision in the ballot, St Nicholas Church remained a part of the Diocese of Hereford.