She has finished in the top ten at three ISU Championships and is the first African American woman to win a Grand Prix medal in the singles discipline.

[9] Making her international debut, she won the junior ladies title at the Golden Bear of Zagreb in October 2016.

[10] After Amber Glenn withdrew, Andrews was added to the U.S. team to the 2017 World Junior Championships in Taipei, Taiwan.

[11] At the event, held in March, she qualified to the final segment by placing ninth in the short program and went on to finish twelfth overall.

In December, making her senior international debut, she placed sixth at the 2017 CS Golden Spin of Zagreb, where she also obtained the minimum technical scores for both senior-level ISU Championships.

In January, Andrews finished sixth in the senior ladies' category at the 2018 U.S. Championships, having placed eighth in the short program and fifth in the free skate.

She attempted the triple Axel in the free program, but her jump had a two-footed landing and was downgraded due to insufficient rotation.

[8] Andrews would place eighth at the 2019 U.S. Championships before going on to win silver at the 2019 International Challenge Cup and the 2019 Egna Spring Trophy.

On the Grand Prix, Andrews placed fourth in the short program at the 2019 Internationaux de France with a new personal best.

She was assigned to compete at the 2020 Skate America in Las Vegas, an event attended only by skaters training in the United States due to the coronavirus pandemic.

[18] Beginning the Olympic season on the Challenger series, Andrews placed fifth at the 2021 CS Autumn Classic International.

"[27] Heading into the 2022 NHK Trophy, she planned to add a second flip to her free skate, having recovered from an ankle "tweak" that had necessitated lessening her content in the early events.

She was ultimately able to begin work on her programs by July, but she did not feature in early domestic and international competitions due both to the delays and to an unrelated illness.

[21] At the 2024 U.S. Championships, Andrews was ninth in the short program but delivered a strong fifth-place free skate and moved up to sixth overall.

[21] In late November, she competed at the 2025 Pacific Coast Sectional Championships, where she won the silver medal, thus qualifying for the U.S.