He also played in the Football League with Notts County, Wycombe Wanderers, Hereford United, Reading and Burnley.
He had a testimonial match with former club Nottingham Forest, in which Chesterfield won 1–0 thanks to a goal by veteran striker Wayne Allison.
He was also registered as a makeshift player but had not been named on any squad sheet due to the injury problems that caused his retirement.
In August 2009, following the dismissal of Steve Charles, Blatherwick and Reeves were appointed joint caretaker managers, but following the completion of one game in this role, the pair departed the club.
He also gained qualifications as an advanced personal trainer, sports therapist and nutritional adviser.