[3] Roger Ebert of the Chicago Sun-Times gave the film 31⁄2 out of 4 stars and wrote positively about the film except for one set-up interview with Cornel West and Tavis Smiley: [Withers] still lives and survives as a happy man.

Still Bill is about a man who topped the charts, walked away from it all in 1985 and is pleased that he did... Perhaps in an attempt to slip some "meaning" into the film, the documentarians Damani Baker and Alex Vlack arrange a conversation with the scholar Cornel West and Tavis Smiley from PBS.

He talks a great deal about his philosophy, to be sure, but it's direct and manifestly true: Make the most of your chances, do the best you can, stop when you're finished, love your family, enjoy life.

[4]Mike Hale of The New York Times also thought the film was well done and mirrored Ebert's position on the interview with West and Smiley: Offstage Bill Withers, the eternal hero of karaoke baritones, exhibits the same gift for aphorism and general soulfulness that informed hit songs like "Lean on Me" and "Ain't No Sunshine."

This makes much of the biographical documentary Still Bill pleasant and even moving... A dialogue among Mr. Withers, the scholar Cornel West and the television host Tavis Smiley feels forced.