In 1962, a permanent building, the Barry Plastics Sports and Social Club pavilion, was erected and formally opened in June.
[1] BP purchased the chemical and plastics interests of The Distillers Company in 1967 and in 1968 took over the Sports and Social Club, supplying subsidies for the various sections including football.
[4] The club won back-to-back South Wales Senior League titles in the 2005–06 and 2006–07 seasons.
[6] They were again back-to-back champions in the 2011–12 season,[7] where they played South Wales Amateur League champions Llantwit Major in the play-off for promotion to the Welsh Football League[8] but lost the match,[9] and in the 2012–13 season[10] where they lost to AFC Rhoose in the corresponding play-off game.
[11] The club moved to the South Wales Alliance League upon its formation and remained in the Premier Division until the end of the 2019–20 season when they were one of five clubs relegated because of changes to the Welsh Football Pyramid ahead of the 2020–21 season.