Birt and team would play in the bronze medal game, where they defeated Switzerland's Silvana Tirinzoni, to place third overall in the competition.
With the departure of Birt's second Robyn MacPhee, PEI Junior Champion Sarah Fullerton, was added to the team for the 2012–2013 season.
In the 2014 Prince Edward Island Scotties Tournament of Hearts, the team had a very poor showing, finishing in last place with a 1–3 record.
Birt formed a brand-new team for the 2015–16 season, which consisted of Robyn MacPhee, Meaghan Hughes and Marie Christianson.
Birt took two seasons off from curling (which included winning $500,000 on an Atlantic Lottery scratch ticket in 2017),[6] to take a "mental break".
Birt skipped team PEI at the 2019 Scotties Tournament of Hearts to a 6–5 finish, good enough for sixth place, but out of the playoffs.
The following season, they won the 2019 Tim Hortons Spitfire Arms Cash Spiel on the tour, and they would defend their provincial title, winning the 2020 Prince Edward Island Scotties Tournament of Hearts in early January 2020.
[12] At the Tournament of Hearts, Birt led her team to a 4–4 round-robin record, failing to qualify for the championship round.
[15][16] Due to the COVID-19 pandemic in Canada, the qualification process for the 2021 Canadian Olympic Curling Trials had to be modified to qualify enough teams for the championship.
[19] The team had two more tour stops during the season, which included winning the Stu Sells 1824 Halifax Classic and reaching the semifinal of the Tim Hortons Spitfire Arms Cash Spiel.
[20] The 2022 Prince Edward Island Scotties Tournament of Hearts was cancelled due to the pandemic and Team Birt were selected to represent their province at the national women's championship.
In October, they won the Superstore Monctonian Challenge with spares Colleen Jones and Sinead Dolan filling in for Marie Christianson and Michelle Shea.
In the new year, they easily won the 2023 Prince Edward Island Scotties Tournament of Hearts, winning all three qualifying events.