[4] As a freshman, she helped her team to earn an invitation to the 1984 NCAA Division I women's volleyball tournament, but they fell in the first round to Oregon.
As a sophomore, the team again earned an invitation to the 1985 NCAA Division I women's volleyball tournament.
They won their first two matches without dropping a set, then faced Pacific for the third time in three year in the regional final.
Eagye would later talk about her "favorite Klum Gym memory ... defeating nemesis Pacific in the 1987 regional".
Eagye scored "the winning points in all three games for Hawai'i by blocking returns across the middle of the net".
[9] Eagye and her teammates had taken a victory lap around the court after defeating Pacific—they would repeat the circuit after the NCAA title match.