[8] Ebanks-Blake returned to England in the summer and signed a three-year deal with Championship club Plymouth Argyle on 14 July 2006.

[16] Having recovered from a calf injury,[17] his final goal of the campaign came against Queens Park Rangers on 18 April 2009, which gave the team the 1–0 win that secured promotion to the Premier League.

After struggling with injuries in early stages of the season, he returned but only managed to score one goal, from the penalty spot (against Aston Villa in October 2009).

[27] Although he was less favoured for a starting berth than Kevin Doyle or new signing Steven Fletcher, he ended the season with seven goals from 28 appearances as the club narrowly avoided relegation on the final day.

[28] In August 2011, he suffered knee ligament damage that put him out of action for six weeks,[29] but when he returned, he was unable to match his goalscoring tally of the previous season as the team struggled against relegation.

He scored only one Premier League goal during the campaign (against Norwich)[30] as the club returned to the Championship under the temporary management of Terry Connor.

[34] He made his debut for the club in the FA Cup third round tie against Preston North End on 4 January 2014, but was substituted off injured after 29 minutes.

[38] He was released in May 2015 following Preston's promotion to the Championship, making 13 appearances in all competitions, his only goal for the club came in the form of a 76th-minute equaliser against Yeovil Town.

[42] He joined the club the following month, making his debut on 25 November in a 4–2 FA Trophy victory over Droylsden, scoring two goals.

[44] Ebanks-Blake joined Halesowen Town on 26 July 2018 to play alongside former West Bromwich Albion striker Lee Hughes.

[47] He scored two goals in five games in the 2018–19 Midland League Premier Division, prior to suffering a serious injury having broken his leg for the third time in his career.

[49] He was subsequently fined £1,350 with £650 costs and £500 compensation by Plymouth Crown Court on 4 July 2008, after admitting to having attacked the doorman with his girlfriend's handbag causing a three-inch cut to his head.