Just before its North American release, Sony selected the game's demo to be included on its PlayStation sampler disc.

Critics applauded the accurate and realistic physics,[6][7][8][9] the mechanics for controlling the ball's release,[7][8][9] and the humorous behavior of the bowlers.

[6][7][8][9] Some critics remarked that the multiplayer capabilities, in combination with its other positive aspects, make Ten Pin Alley an ideal party video game.

"[8] GamePro summarized, "Striking sparks into the world of bowling, Ten Pin Alley delivers enough fun per frame to be recognized as the kingpin of its sport.

[10] Ten Pin Alley was inducted into the International Bowling Hall of Fame in 1997, with an exhibit including an interactive kiosk.