He played college football for the American International Yellow Jackets, where he was a two-time All-New England selection.
"[2] He noted that he "wasn't a good hitter" and quit the sport in favor of track and field; then he switched to football.
[2] The two Randolphs attended Samuel J. Tilden High School in Brooklyn, New York; Terry was a quarterback in football and was teammates with his brother for one year, although Willie focused on baseball.
[6] Randolph was named the 1978 President's Cup winner as the top senior athlete at American International.
[2] Despite facing an "uphill battle" due to his low draft selection and new position, Randolph was able to make the final roster.