FC Dallas claimed the 2008 series on the away goals rule, after having tied with Dynamo in all three games played that season.
The tiebreakers couldn't separate the teams in 2017 so Houston retained El Capitán.
If the series is tied, the tiebreakers are as follows: Bold indicates a player who is still on a FC Dallas or Houston Dynamo roster.
Bold indicates a player who is still on a FC Dallas or Houston Dynamo roster.
Bold indicates a player who is still on a FC Dallas or Houston Dynamo roster.