They were originally a piano trio, but became a quartet in 2021: founding members Reid Anderson on bass and David King on drums, as well as guitarist Ben Monder and tenor saxophonist Chris Speed.

After parting ways with Columbia, the group signed to Heads Up Records (a division of Telarc), and released the album Prog in 2007.

They noted that the band would no longer be a "piano trio (for now, at least)" and that "they are looking forward to expanding the ensemble as they work on creating music for their next record.

The band have recorded versions of songs by Nirvana, Aphex Twin, Blondie, Peter Gabriel, Pink Floyd, Ornette Coleman, Pixies, Rush, Tears for Fears, Neil Young, David Bowie, Yes, Interpol, The Flaming Lips,[9] Johnny Cash, The Bee Gees, Burt Bacharach, Cyndi Lauper and Black Sabbath.

contains a cover of the theme from "Chariots of Fire", while a version of "Karma Police" by Radiohead appeared on the 2006 album Exit Music: Songs with Radio Heads.