The band recorded the album with producer Ken Andrews (Pete Yorn, Mae) in Los Angeles in spring 2007.

[citation needed] A special edition of The Flame In All of Us was released simultaneously, with a DVD detailing the making of the record.

[citation needed] The band's front man Trevor McNevan describes the concept as "No Matter what you believe or where you were raised, you have the same core group of questions as the next person, who am I?

The album's style ranges from heavy metal on tracks "Falls Apart" and "Inhuman" to softer rock on "What Do We Know" and "Wish You Well".

"[5] Production Additional musicians Family Christian Stores exclusive: "The Flame in all of Us" has two music videos, more than any other TFK album.

The "Falls Apart" video starts off showing the band in a dark wood room, with lots of rope around them.