Cassie Nightingale (Catherine Bell) has settled into Middleton and is busy making Grey House into a bed and breakfast.

Her boyfriend, Chief of Police Jake Russell (Chris Potter), and his kids, Brandon (Matthew Knight) and Lori (Hannah Endicott-Douglas), are happy to have Cassie in the neighborhood, but before long, a stranger named Nick (Rob Stewart) appears.

Papers prove this entitlement to legal ownership, yet Jake Russell is suspicious and eager to help a bewildered Cassie.

Jake arrests Nick after discovering the man is using one of many fake identities taken on to con rightful owners out of their properties.

The movie ends with a garden party held at Cassie's, where Martha Tisdale finally accepts her as a valuable member of the community.