Written by David H. Goodman & Brigitte Hales, and directed by Geofrey Hildrew, it premiered on ABC in the United States on April 20, 2018.

In the episode, Weaver takes matters into his own hands when his dagger is stolen, while Margot and Tilly go on their first date, and Henry is conflicted over the truth that he could be Lucy's father.

As he deals with the loss of his wife, Facilier shows up and offers a chance to communicate with Belle by having Rumplestiltskin give up his dagger in exchange.

Hours later and with the Darkness ready to consume him, Rumplestiltskin got the opportunity to see Alice and tells her that he has a way to break the curse put on her father's heart and that Facilier has the magic they need, but he won't give it up without a fight.

Weaver later resorted to desperate measures by stealing the magic ingredients from Regina without her knowing in order to create a tracker spell, which eventually leads him to Tilly.

The voices Tilly was hearing were coming from the dagger itself, in her backpack, thus revealing her to Weaver as the Guardian, but at the same time he believes that she didn't take the weapon.

He later asks Rogers (who was checking surveillance to see who last visited Hansel but Samdi had it altered) to return to the apartment to find the evidence.

As the two return to the apartment, Henry finds the paperwork, but then he and Rogers hear sounds and chase down the intruder, who they discover is Drew.

When they see the autopsy results, they discover Nick died from a stab, but from within instead of outside the body, Rogers begins to suspect something isn't right in this town, as Drew alluded earlier.